Sunday, 15 May 2005

Berman fatigue

I am in general agreement with Steven Taylor’s assessment of the final two episodes of Star Trek: Enterprise; indeed, I think “Terra Prime” probably would have functioned just as well if it had been the finale. Plus, I really liked the fact they actually found something useful to do with Travis Mayweather—I think he had more lines in the “Demons/Terra Prime” two-parter than he’d had in whole seasons; he certainly had more useful things to do. I still have to wonder what bizarre fashion trend made everyone on Earth abandon normal clothing in favor of jumpsuits between 216x and the TOS era, however.

As for the finale itself, I can’t agree more with this statement:

Unfortunately These are the Voyages underscores Berman’s lack of understanding of what should have been done with Enterprise–here is the chance to focus on the founding of the Federation and instead we get a side-story about Shran’s kidnapped daughter and the ramifications of that event, including the poorly written, poorly acted, gratuitous death of Trip. One tunes in assuming that the story would be about the decommissioning of Enterprise and the signing of the Federation Charter, and yet we don’t actually get to see any of it (save a few minutes in the final act).

The surrounding story on the Enterprise-D made little sense, didn’t fit in with the events it supposedly was a part of, and was really quite unsatisfactory—and I actually like Riker and Troi, unlike a goodly portion of the fan base. About the only good thing about the episode was its showcasing of Connor Trinneer—and the D/TP two-parter did a better job of that too.

In other sci-fi news, Friday also saw Andromeda finally put out of its (and my) misery. The scary thing is that the best sci-fi on Friday night was probably the damn rerun of Battlestar Galactica’s “Litmus,” and it was barely sci-fi at all. I also learned about the Monty Hall Dilemma on Numb3ers, which you’d think I’d have known as an applied stats guy but it somehow never came up.

Of course, I didn’t see any of this live since I was actually in Pearl at the time watching the Mississippi Braves at Trustmark Park, courtesy of friends-of-friends Michelle and David.

1 comment:

Any views expressed in these comments are solely those of their authors; they do not reflect the views of the authors of Signifying Nothing, unless attributed to one of us.

Here in the Mempho, they only showed the first part of the Andromeda two-part finale. Next Sunday at midnight on WMC/5, we get the end. That show has so sucked this year. Can’t believe how the vast space opera of the first season got turned into some sad-sack proto-Western by the end.

And the Trek finale, TaTV, really sucked. They wait to the last episode to announce that the chef has been the ship’s confidant. And here I thought it was Phlox, based on all those conversations we’ve seen. We see Archer and his damned water polo ball! Hadn’t they already buried that shame? They build up this huge speech and then don’t show it. (Although Lileks thinks that was the point and a good one.)

Trip and T’Pol, after the amazing emotional moment at the end of Terra Prime, decide to cool it for six years. Six years!! No one’s gotten a promotion or left the ship, nor has a new person joined the core crew in all that time.

And Trip died so Archer could make yet another conference.

Gah.

 
Comments are now closed on this post.