Sunday, 28 November 2004

Filibustering judicial nominees

George Will has yet another column, this one in Newsweek, on the merits of the filibuster, even against judicial nominees:

The president should renominate all 10 appellate-court nominees who have been filibustered, and he should vow, like General Grant, to “fight it out on this line, if it takes all summer.” Norman Ornstein, a student of these things, says Senate Republicans could force Democrats to conduct the kind of filibuster Southern Democrats conducted against civil-rights legislation in the 1950s—talking around the clock, the obstructionists and their opponents sleeping on cots in the Capitol, the Senate paralyzed. There has never been such a spectacle in the era of C-Span and saturation journalism on cable 24 hours a day. Do Democrats want to make 2005 the year of living dangerously? Seventeen of their 44 seats are at risk in 2006—five of them in states Bush just carried.
Will has a good point about filibusters being designed for even an intense minority, which the Democrats certainly are these days. I’m still a bit skeptical since the constitution says the Senate must advise and consent, but mentions nothing about stopping floor votes or the judicial committee.

Even so, it’s something I could respect if the Republicans and President Bush would hold their feet to the fire and force an old-fashioned filibuster: make them sleep in the Senate chamber. Bring business to a halt and fight it out. I doubt the Republicans have the ‘nads to do so.

2 comments:

Any views expressed in these comments are solely those of their authors; they do not reflect the views of the authors of Signifying Nothing, unless attributed to one of us.

I don’t think the filibuster is quite the weapon for the majority you (and Will) make it out to be; see e.g. here and here.

 
[Permalink] 2. Jon Henke wrote @ Mon, 29 Nov 2004, 9:47 am CST:

Damned happy to see you back in the saddle, Robert. Just added you guys to the blogroll, and I look forward to reading your stuff again.

 
Comments are now closed on this post.